Caught in an Endless Cycle – Why Yelling “Karma” Misses the Mark

David Rosenzweig Uncategorized 3 Comments

Last week, the New York Times published a widely read report detailing an incident in which three suspected rhino poachers were eaten by a pride of lions in the Sibuya Game Reserve of South Africa. Rather than detail the events that transpired, you can go ahead and read the Times report found here – NY Times Report Lions eat Poachers.

Game Reserves in the Eastern Cape are incredibly well managed, with many home to various prides of lions

In case you choose not to read the report, here’s an executive summary:
• On July 2nd, 2018 three suspected poachers entered the Sibuya Private Game Reserve in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa
• Armed with axes and high-powered rifles, these poachers were believed to have been after the park’s rhino population
• On the black market, rhino horn can fetch upwards of $65,000 per kilogram which has led to an exponential rise in rhino poaching across the continent. This has led some experts to estimate that rhinos in South Africa could go extinct in the next 15-20 years
• On July 3rd, the anti-poaching unit at Sibuya located the remains of three individuals in the immediate vicinity of a pride of lions in addition to gloves and a rifle
• A forensics team was called in immediately and the lions were sedated to take samples

Immediately after the report came out and big outlets such as National Geographic and CNN picked up the story, the topic became an international conversation. And just like any national news, opinions on the events were screamed into the abyss. Twitter was set ablaze, yet perhaps not in the light you may have expected. Celebrity advocates took to the platform to decry “Karma!” There were op-ed posts, such as this one from Vice News, hinting to “not mess with the animal kingdom.” And the Telegraph went as far as to question this as “Fair Game.”

Now, let me be clear about one thing: I am in no way defending the actions of poachers in any way, shape, or form. Those that are close to me know that I have dedicated the greater part of the past five years of my life to rhino conservation and the preservation of the species moving forward. But hearing such reactions across the main-stream media, I just couldn’t help but feel unsettled about our approach.

You see, the three people killed by these lions played just a tiny piece in the vast and intricate puzzle that is a poaching king-pin.

With no end of poaching in sight, some conservationists have advocated for dehorning as a method of protecting rhinos

So I challenge you to put yourself in the following situation:

Imagine you’re a farmer living on the fringes of the Sibuya Game Reserve in South Africa making no more than $6 a day. You have a family of seven that you need to support. You are living in absolute poverty and struggle to find the next meal day-to-day. Then, a BMW rolls up to your doorstep. Out steps a man of Asian-descent carrying a briefcase. He proceeds to explain to you the opportunity of a lifetime: he will pay you $2,000 if you are able to provide him with the horn of an African rhino. $2,000. That’s almost one year’s worth of work all at one time! So, what would you do? Do you take the risk of venturing into the bushveld in an effort to hit it rich? Or do you tell him no?

Not so simple now is it?

Now, of course this is not saying that the poacher is right by his decision. But simply put the issue is not so cut and dry. Especially in a country like South Africa, which exhibits the highest levels of economic inequality in the world, such problems must be acknowledged in terms of their complexity and addressed as such.

Were the three men eaten by lions in the Sibuya Reserve of South Africa violent murderers set on a path to destroy a species? Or did they fall victim to a malevolent poaching syndicate intent on supplying a black-market demand no matter what the costs?

There is a greater target for public scrutiny and dismay; and it is one that has not nearly received as much condemnation and investigation as it deserves.

———-

So what are your thoughts on this hot-button issue? Am I going to easy on the suspected poachers? Where have I missed the mark? Let’s start a dialogue – I’d love to hear your thoughts!

 

-David Rosenzweig

Share this Post

About the Author

David Rosenzweig

Facebook

I am a 20 year old student studying at Stanford University with a passion for wildlife photography and conservation. After my first trip to Africa 6 years ago, I caught the Africa bug and was hooked. Fast forward to today and I have found my place within this photographic community. Although now my focus must shift to my studies, this blog will be used as an outlet for me to share my ideas with the wildlife photography world. I will be posting on a range of topics from trip reports to conservation stories and everything in between. I hope you follow along on this exciting new journey! You can check out my website at davidrphotos.com or follow me on Instagram. Thanks for reading!

Comments 3

  1. Tajin Olusegun Taire

    You asked if the three killed were desperate to make a years wages in a brew days regardless of the cost. Nuff said brother.

    They had a choice, the one they took ended them in the bellies of lions … tough shit!

    Billions face similar choices with drugs, prostitution gang life, etc, in inner cities all over the world … and end up with tough shit too!

    And billions go through a life of less than dollar a day, in urban and rural settings in Africa and all over the world … and surmount it by excelling or doing OK in all walks of life.

    If all the rural Africans in the bushveldt refused to poach Rhino, rich kingpin poachers wouldn’t approach them … especially if they are instructed unofficially to beat anyone who approaches them to a pulp. Then let’s see how many kingpins, or dare devil African ‘entrepreneurs’ would attempt to enter the bush by themselves and risk their lives against the villagers and the wild animals.

    I will rejoice whenever anyone, rich or poor, is killed by animals while attempting to kill animals in the bush for profit. if they want to make money from animals there are plenty of opportunities for entrepreneurs and workers in agricultural animal husbandry. And if animals aren’t their thing, there are plenty of other industries to choose from.

    And if they dont like to take risks in business or take jobs to make ends meet until something else comes along, and therefore to take risks with their lives instead for faster money … again I say … TOUGH SHIT!

    The government and any and all sensible people should support more out of the box measures which expose poachers rich and poor to grave danger … BECAUSE WE ARE THE LINE OF DEFENCE FOR THE ANIMALS AGAINST HUMAN GREED!

    That’s my humble opinion!

    1. Post
      Author
      David Rosenzweig

      Hi Tajin,

      Thank you for your reply. Your emotive and passionate response is certainly one shared amongst many in the conservation community.

      However, I want to provide a bit of pushback. Of course it is true that as you say “if all the rural Africans in the bushveld refused to poach Rhino, rich kingpin poachers wouldn’t approach them.” But this is simply not a reality anywhere in the world you go.

      If given the chance to travel to the African continent, you will observe that the rampant economic inequality and social fragmentation make for a situation much more dire than the one we all hope for. Simply put, if any single one of those poachers said “No I won’t do it,” the kingpin would just go next door and find a likely suitor.

      Again I am not defending the poaching of rhinos in any which way, just questioning whether talks of “karma” lead to anywhere constructive. Rather we should be advancing criminal investigations and prosecuting those who are at the tops of these syndicates.

      Let me know your thoughts!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *